(This post is a
follow-up to this post. Readers are advised to read that one first.)
“My zeal consumes me,
because my foes forget your words.” (Ps. 119:139, ESV)
The Pharisees in the Gospels are not portrayed
in a favorable light. Over and over Jesus warns his followers to not imitate
them. They were proud, self-righteous, didn’t practice what they preached and
focused on their own interpretation of the law rather than what God intended.
No Christian wants to find out they are like the Pharisees. I tread on rather
dangerous ground even hinting that this could happen, but to not do so, I
believe would be pharisaical itself.
I read a book some time ago called Accidental
Pharisees (you can read my summary of it here). This is a fantastic book but not an easy read
as it reminded me that all of us have same tendencies and
sin-inclinations that the pharisees had and that it is deceptively easy to
slide into self-righteousness and pride. (Lord, may this not be me right
now!)
We have a problem in the church today. When
confronted with abuse, churches are not handling it in godly, Biblical ways but
rather in ways that fit with their pre-disposed ideas. With abusive
marriages particularly, often church leaders value the marriage over the
individual people. As a result, they minimize the abuser’s behavior, believe
him over her and even shift the focus and blame on the victim for wanting out of the
marriage. This type of thinking and action is seen fairly often in patriarchal
churches that hold to an unbalance of power in marriage, for, “When taken to
their logical conclusion, the teachings of patriarchal authoritarianism groom
men to become dictators, and condition women to accept abuse as God’s will.”
(From Fractured Covenants, see my last post). Like the Pharisees, they
focus on the “letter of the law” rather than the person and the situation – the
real heart of the issue. Their focus is on “saving the marriage” rather
than dealing with the real sin issue and rescuing a sister in
Christ.
When I was getting my counseling degree from
Westminster Theological Seminary through Christian Counseling Educational
Foundation, one of the most impactful classes I took was an observation class
with Darby Stickland where we watched her counsel a couple where the husband was emotionally abusive. It was incredibly eye-opening. The husband was an EXACT match for the
descriptions of an abusive person given in chapter 1 of Fractured Covenants
(See under heading “Where Does Subtler Mistreatment End, and Abuse Begin?” See
also additional descriptions in chapter 2). And the poor wife, she was so
conditioned that she had no idea she was innocent – and that he was
the problem! It was beautiful seeing the understanding dawn in her face as
she realized the way he was treating her was wrong and that she had done nothing
to deserve it. It was tragic to see a woman stuck in such an awful situation.
In 1 Cor. 5:11, it says this: “But
now I am writing to you not to associate with anyone who bears the name
of brother if he is guilty of sexual immorality or greed, or is an
idolater, reviler, drunkard, or swindler - not even to eat with such a one.” You
can be a practicing adulterer, reviler, drunkard, or you can be a Christian. You
can’t be both. “In fact, according to this text, a reviler who calls
himself a brother is far, far worse than an outright unbeliever. A reviler who
is allowed to call himself a brother will corrupt the whole church” (Fractured
Covenants, and see here). Many abusers pass themselves off as “good Christian men”
but in reality, in secret, are slanderers and revilers of their wives. Jesus
had a lot to say about these kinds of people: “Woe to you, teachers of the law
and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You are like whitewashed tombs, which look
beautiful on the outside but on the inside are full of the bones of the dead
and everything unclean. In the same way, on the outside you appear to people
as righteous but on the inside you are full of hypocrisy and wickedness”
(Matthew 23:27-28).
When church leaders misplace blame and demand a
woman return to an abusive husband – especially one who claims to be a
Christian - they are disobeying 1 Cor. 5:11 and the rest of Scripture
which says over and over to rescue those who are oppressed (see Psalm 82:3-4,
Lev. 19:15, and many others). Doing so they spiritually abuse their
position and add to the victims suffering by using Scripture against her and
disciplining her for fleeing her abuser. Jesus had a lot to say about these
kinds of people too:
“Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You
give a tenth of your spices—mint, dill and cumin. But you have neglected the
more important matters of the law—justice, mercy and faithfulness. You
should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former. You blind
guides! … You snakes! You brood of vipers! How will you escape being condemned
to hell? Therefore I am sending you prophets and sages and teachers. Some of
them you will kill and crucify; others you will flog in your synagogues and
pursue from town to town. And so upon you will come all the righteous blood
that has been shed on earth...” (Matthew 23:23-24, 34-36, NIV)
These words are incredibly harsh and
frightening. Not only do these kinds of people persecute the righteous, but
they risk going to hell.
In the book, Fractured Covenants, the
author shares much of her own story of abuse in her marriage and her church’s
tragic, abusive response. While initially supportive, her two pastors chose
to side with her husband and, despite acknowledging she was a victim,
still demanded that she return to him. In a letter to her (after she
had resigned her membership) in which they threaten church discipline they
write, “Our first and greatest concern is that you chose to
divorce…”. (This and subsequent quotes taken directly from the letter from the
church pastors which you can read here.) Their first and
greatest concern was not over the sin HE had committed towards her, it was
not that SHE needed safety and healing…. It was that she was
(apparently) sinning by divorcing this man who repeatedly and unrepentantly
verbally, spiritually and emotionally abused her. Again, while the leaders acknowledge the
abuse, they still somehow believed that she was the one “breaking (the)
marriage covenant”. They claimed she didn’t “attempt to address his sins” or
“didn’t want help or counsel”, (quote) which was not true – they
had done counseling, she'd tried to get help about his problems but nothing changed. He wasn’t
willing to change – that was the issue. Of course, he feigned sorrow and
“repentance” to the pastors, but then he turned around and continued in his
verbal abuse and antagonism towards her. This is completely typical of abusers.
Yet the pastors, these “blind guides,” naively believed him over her – and
subsequently sought to discipline her because she had “wandered from
the truth” (quote). What “truth” is that exactly? How could she seek to
“preserve the marriage” (quote) when her husband was the one breaking
the marriage covenant? Is this what God intended when He created marriage?
Is this the kind of leadership and ministry God calls pastors to?
As for the church leaders who so sinned against
her, God will judge them for downplaying and even condoning the sin of the
men in their congregation and for shooting their own wounded.
Brothers and sisters, we cannot tolerate,
excuse or downplay abuse. It is sinful, demonic and damaging. It is a sin
against the man to leave him in his sin, a sin against the woman to leave her
in her suffering or hurt her further, and a sin against the local church and
the church at large (in showing how we handle sin and oppression) and to Christ
Himself. Proverbs says that, “He who justifies the wicked and he who
condemns the righteous, both of them alike are an abomination to the LORD”
(Prov 17:15) and Jesus Himself said, “For in the same way you judge others,
you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you”
(Matt. 7:2). Let us not be like the Pharisees, let us not imitate or follow those
who value their interpretation of Scripture over the soul of one oppressed. Let
us believe those who come to us with their stories of abuse and rescue them
from the hands of the wicked.
You can read about the
events in this particular case for yourself in Fractured Covenants and in THIS article on Marie's story.
For additional reading: Spiritual Abuse in Marriage
For additional reading: Spiritual Abuse in Marriage